Estera Sava
19 Nov 2026 / 8 Min Read
Gabriel Lucas, Director of Payments Advisory at Redbridge Debt and Treasury Advisory, discusses why A2A payments were never a full replacement for cards.
The debate around account-to-account (A2A) payments is usually framed as a contest between A2A payments and card schemes. It is a tidy story of new rails, lower costs, faster settlement, and fewer intermediaries, in which A2A payments slowly displace cards and schemes fade.
I think the framing is wrong. A2A payments were never really about replacing schemes. They were about improving how money moves, which is only one part of making a payment system work at scale, and a relevant distinction to keep in mind.
As I argued in ‘A2A payments: the missed opportunity?’, account-based payments offer merchants genuine benefits: faster settlement, lower cost, better control over cash flow. This is not a theory. Open Banking, instant rails, Pix, UPI, iDEAL, SEPA Instant, and Pay by Bank all show that A2A creates real value in the right markets and use cases.
So, the question is not whether an A2A payment works. It does. The harder question is: can the system around A2A payments generate the trust, governance, incentives, and value needed to scale beyond domestic, low-margin payments?
Card schemes are often dismissed as rails. That is too narrow. Their strength is structural, not just technical: common rules, acceptance standards, dispute and chargeback mechanisms, liability models, fraud frameworks, settlement, and, crucially, a commercial model that gives every participant a reason to keep investing, something most people underestimate.
A scheme is not a network of participants. It is a system of incentives, including: interchange, scheme fees, processing revenue fund resilience, security, innovation, rewards, risk management, and global acceptance. The model is expensive, often criticised, and imperfect, but it is proven self-sustaining.
A2A payments have not yet become the equivalent, but it’s interesting to look at what happens when they try.
Take the two systems most often cited as evidence that A2A payments are winning:
India’s UPI has reached an extraordinary scale. However, its zero-MDR economics are a policy paid for by the state, not a market outcome. The government allocated around EUR 135 million to incentivise low-value UPI transactions for 2024-25, after roughly EUR 325 million in 2023-24, and industry bodies have lobbied since 2023 to introduce an MDR. A ‘free’ rail that depends on a recurring, contested government subsidy is not a sustainable economic model. It is a political one, and the moment credit enters UPI, scheme economics reappear: RuPay credit on UPI already carries an MDR of roughly 1.1% to 2% above about EUR 18. The free rail stays free, while the value-added layer gets monetised, which is not a coincidence.
Brazil’s Pix tells the same story even more clearly. Pix is one of the most successful instant payment systems in the world. But it is no longer staying a simple rail. The Central Bank launched Pix Automático for recurring payments in 2025; banks are now offering instalments over Pix as an interest-bearing alternative to credit cards; and the Central Bank is developing a mechanism, expected in 2026 or 2027, to let businesses pledge future Pix receivables as collateral for credit. Recurring billing, instalments, credit overlays, receivables financing: that is Pix rebuilding, piece by piece, exactly the layers that make a scheme a scheme. The UK makes the point most explicitly of all. Variable Recurring Payments (VRPs) already work for ‘sweeping’ between a customer’s own accounts, and they are free. VRPs now account for around 16% of Open Banking transactions, with much of that growth through sweeping. But the moment the industry tried to extend them to commercial use, recurring bills, subscriptions, and eventually ecommerce, it ran into the obvious problem: free funds no one.
So, in 2025, 31 firms came together to establish the UK Payments Initiative (UKPI) to drive commercial VRPs and agreed to a first-phase commercial model, with the first live payments expected in early 2026. At its core sits a centralised access fee, which the regulator has chosen not to challenge, and a purchase-protection model for ecommerce VRPs, explicitly benchmarked against debit cards. A central body, a shared commercial model, an access fee, and dispute protection, modelled on cards – they are not replacing the scheme model, but instead rebuilding it, in the open, and calling it Open Banking.
This is what often gets missed: flagship A2A systems are not scheme economics replacements but reconstructions.
There is a second reason the ‘A2A payments replace cards’ story breaks down: it targets the wrong profit pool.
As we explored in ‘Why Pay by Bank is the Hottest Trend in Global Payments’, merchants have strong reasons to push A2A payments: cost, settlement speed, lower fraud exposure, and cash flow. For high-ticket or low-margin sectors, this is compelling.
But today, A2A competes mostly with domestic debit and bank transfers, the thinnest margin market corner. The real economic value comes from international, credit, premium, and rewards-led spending, where interchange, FX, lending, and loyalty stack up. This is the pool that schemes defend hardest, and it is precisely where A2A payment has made least progress.
Which is why understanding card economics, including interchange, still matters, especially in markets like the US, where rewards and credit are deeply embedded. We covered that complexity in ‘Understanding US interchange fees: a guide for European merchants’.
Simply put, cheaper doesn’t mean better. A2A can be cheaper because it strips out parts of the card economics, but removing them is not the same as replacing them with something that works.
A sustainable payment system needs governance: clear rules, trusted brands, consistent dispute and refund processes, liability allocation, and fraud controls. And it needs value creation that reaches everyone in the chain, from merchants, banks, and PSPs to consumers and infrastructure providers. Without that, A2A is a very efficient rail with an incomplete ecosystem around it. For this reason, schemes or scheme-like models will stay central.
So, the future is not A2A versus schemes, but A2A plus the network model that makes it work. In the markets that matter most, this is being built on top of A2A, not instead of it.
Who builds it? My call is that the winning overlay will not come from a new A2A-native challenger trying to dethrone the schemes. Rebuilding trust, rules, and economics from zero, at the same time, is the hardest job in payments, and very few have the balance sheet or the patience for it. Domestically, the winners will be public rail operators and banks that layer credit and value-added services on A2A. Pix is the template.
Cross-border and in high-value pools, incumbent schemes will extend downward and absorb A2A into their own networks rather than be replaced by them. The closest thing to a genuine new entrant will be a wallet or super-app with distribution it already owns, but that, too, is just scheme-like economics rebuilt by someone with reach. The ‘scheme killer’ is the least likely outcome of all.
A2A means building better rails, while the economics are being rebuilt right behind them, mostly by players who already understood how they worked.
This editorial piece was first published in The Paypers' Account-to-Account Payments Report 2026, which features insights into global trends, technologies, partnerships, and the next phase of the A2A evolution. Access the full report to understand where the A2A payments ecosystem stands today and what’s next.

Leading the European team at Redbridge Payments Advisory, Gabriel Lucas has been providing strategic advice to international and multichannel merchants in their payment transformation and optimisation journeys since 2020. He previously worked for four years as Chief Operating Officer at a France-based Electronic Money Institution (EMI) specialised in alternative payment methods.
Redbridge Debt and Treasury Advisory is a leading financial management partner to corporations around the globe. It is committed to providing each client with all the information required to make the best decisions and optimise their financial performance. Redbridge’s teams are located in Houston, New York, Chicago, Paris, Geneva, and London.
The Paypers is a global hub for market insights, real-time news, expert interviews, and in-depth analyses and resources across payments, fintech, and the digital economy. We deliver reports, webinars, and commentary on key topics, including regulation, real-time payments, cross-border payments and ecommerce, digital identity, payment innovation and infrastructure, Open Banking, Embedded Finance, crypto, fraud and financial crime prevention, and more – all developed in collaboration with industry experts and leaders.
Current themes
No part of this site can be reproduced without explicit permission of The Paypers (v2.7).
Privacy Policy / Cookie Statement
Copyright